Some questions for Ahl-e-Tashee Hazrat, please remain cool and help everyone explain the possible answers to these, also point out if these questions are based on wrong assumptions!
1. How many times do we see Hazrat Ali (r.a) saying anything against Hazrat Abu Bakar (r.a), Hazrat Omar and Hazrat Usman (r.a) in his lifetime, let alone revolting against them?
2. Why did Hazrat Ali (r.a) asked his two beloved sons Hassan (r.a) and Hussain (r.a) to protect Hazrat Usman (r.a) when they were attacked by miscreants?
3. Why did Hazrat Hassan (r.a) did signed an unconditional peace treaty with Hazrat Mawiya (r.a.) to end the conflict which erupted after the death of Hazrat Usman (r.a)?
4. Assuming that all sahaba-e-kiram were human beings therefore must have committed some mistakes and sins, also there must be degrees seniority among in terms of piety and closeness with Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w)... having said this name one scholar from last two hundred years at least from any school of thought of Islam who can be declared superior than the dust underneath the feet of sahabi of least seniority? if the answer is no then who have the right to dislike or blame any sahabi, even if we assume that some of them did committed some mistake, just for the sake of argument.
5. How can we say that the greatest man in the history of mankind, a messenger of Allah (s.w.t), receiving guidance directly from Allah (s.w.t), unmatched in his wisdom, insight, intelligence etc, remain oblivious that some of his closest companions (on whom ahle-e-tashee hazrat points fingers) are hypocrites, and even got no warning in his lifetime from Allah (s.w.t) about their hypocrisy? Isn't it a great disrespect to the Prophet (s.a.w) himself?
6. What is the source of legitimacy of all the brutal rituals performed during 10th Muharram, is doing all that like following Prophet (s.a.w) or his companions (r.a)? Would Hazrat Hasan (r.a), Hazrat Hussain (r.a) and Hazrat Ali (r.a) would have approved all that? If not then how Allah (s.w.t) will approve the pain and misery caused in all that?
The purpose is to understand the point of view, so kindly provide answers which clarify the above so that the minds of others is cleared!
kind regards...
1. How many times do we see Hazrat Ali (r.a) saying anything against Hazrat Abu Bakar (r.a), Hazrat Omar and Hazrat Usman (r.a) in his lifetime, let alone revolting against them?
2. Why did Hazrat Ali (r.a) asked his two beloved sons Hassan (r.a) and Hussain (r.a) to protect Hazrat Usman (r.a) when they were attacked by miscreants?
3. Why did Hazrat Hassan (r.a) did signed an unconditional peace treaty with Hazrat Mawiya (r.a.) to end the conflict which erupted after the death of Hazrat Usman (r.a)?
4. Assuming that all sahaba-e-kiram were human beings therefore must have committed some mistakes and sins, also there must be degrees seniority among in terms of piety and closeness with Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w)... having said this name one scholar from last two hundred years at least from any school of thought of Islam who can be declared superior than the dust underneath the feet of sahabi of least seniority? if the answer is no then who have the right to dislike or blame any sahabi, even if we assume that some of them did committed some mistake, just for the sake of argument.
5. How can we say that the greatest man in the history of mankind, a messenger of Allah (s.w.t), receiving guidance directly from Allah (s.w.t), unmatched in his wisdom, insight, intelligence etc, remain oblivious that some of his closest companions (on whom ahle-e-tashee hazrat points fingers) are hypocrites, and even got no warning in his lifetime from Allah (s.w.t) about their hypocrisy? Isn't it a great disrespect to the Prophet (s.a.w) himself?
6. What is the source of legitimacy of all the brutal rituals performed during 10th Muharram, is doing all that like following Prophet (s.a.w) or his companions (r.a)? Would Hazrat Hasan (r.a), Hazrat Hussain (r.a) and Hazrat Ali (r.a) would have approved all that? If not then how Allah (s.w.t) will approve the pain and misery caused in all that?
The purpose is to understand the point of view, so kindly provide answers which clarify the above so that the minds of others is cleared!
kind regards...
The title of your article "Some Humble Questions for Ahl-e-Tashee Hazrat" is deceptive and not true because if you were humble with your questions, you would first and foremost publish all the comments people send you, good or bad and let others decide for themselves.
ReplyDeleteI sent you a comment on this article about 5 days ago but to my surprise, it was never published.
So what is exactly humble about you my brother? I would love to be wrong in my view and hope that you will do what you are supposed to insha Allah.
apologies, i deleted one comment some time back by mistake, yours comment is the first detailed one! and i haven't received any other comments on this post! don't worry i will post all comments as they arrive, if they don't violate the commenting policy :)... jazakallah khair
Delete